Page 7

Assessor, REBECCA M. TONIGAN, C.I.A.O.

          Property Taxes and the Real Estate Market  

    

       Due to the present downturn in the real estate market and the ongoing media coverage, property owners believe there has been a severe loss of market value in property values in our township. The property tax system is a complex process, and when one adds in the currently  challenged real estate market, the process becomes even more difficult to understand.

      Despite the reports of housing values plunging downward, foreclosures at an all time high, and homes simply not selling at seemingly any price, property taxes continue to rise. This is a very challenging concept for property owners to accept. Many homeowners must feel that our office is not properly reacting to market conditions.

The Assessor is responsible for assessing property at one-third of the fair market value. Properties are valued as of January 1st of each year. However, the county and the state monitor assessor values so that values throughout the county and state are equitably assessed. This year our equalization factor is 4.93% which is placed on each property by the County.  I have no control over this factor.  The formulas that are used to measure our accuracy and equity  always include consideration of actual sales over a three-year period as required by law. Therefore when our office valued properties for January 1st, 2008, we were obligated to look back at the sales that took place during 2007, 2006, and 2005. We are not permitted to just look at the market place that existed on January 1st, 2008.

Below, is a chart of sales activity in Cuba Township for the past five years. As you can see, the market was in a rising trend during 2004, 2005, and most of 2006. But in 2007 it appeared to stabilize and so far in 2008 the number of sales dropped off sharply, however, the sales prices continued to be stable in 2007 but are dropping in 2008. There is no indication in our township of excessive decrease in property values as measured by the actual sales taking place. The law also does not allow our office to consider non-arms-length sales such as foreclosures.

All of this simply means that there can be no immediate reduction of assessments based on the available data and the current laws that govern the process. The data does show a definite slowdown in the local market, particularly in the number of homes sold. Please be assured that our office will continue to closely monitor the sales activity in the market and adjust assessments accordingly.

Most importantly, everyone should understand that regardless of what happens in the market place and even if assessments were to be reduced, this does not mean that property taxes will go down. Please remember that property taxes pay for local services such as schools, parks, police, fire protection, and if these local units continue to provide services and increase spending , then property taxes will continue to increase. This process was explained in my last newsletter and can be found on our website @ www.cubatownshipassessor.com.

Please know that our office is painfully aware of the challenges being faced by those who are trying to sell their home in this very difficult market. We will continue to monitor the sale activity in our township and calculate the assessments based on that market, as measured over a 3-year period (as required by state law). For the assessment date January 1, 2009, we will look at sales in 2008, 2007, and 2006.

I hope this article helps explain the assessment process and how it relates to current housing market conditions.

 

YEAR

NO. OF SALES

MEDIAN SALE

AVERAGE SALE

SALES RANGE

2004

366

471,250

533,210

18,500  to  2,334,500

2005

418

460,000

611,521

122,900  to  16,500,000

2006

301

510,000

602,976

5,214  to  3,360,000

2007

232

528,750

622,721

164,000  to  2,825,000

*2008

52

482,500

548,275

170,000  to  2,600,000

 

*The 2008 sales are only through May 2008.

page 1 page 2 page 3 page 4 page 5 page 6 page 7 page 8